Talk:Major Completed Quests: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
(Vague policy get) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
The given criteria so far seem to be "completed series quest that someone cared enough to add". There are probably more that could be added (which is why I added the completion dates in comments. Will make inserting new entries easier for whoever does it). Some discussion with Brom after Oren finished prompted the addition of Shoujin and Knight Blades (so Larro's got something in at least. The Game, Sevi, and My Life are his other completed quests- not sure if they count as major or not). I also feel like some of Shot's completed text quests might deserve to be in here. ...main thing holding me back is I haven't gotten around to reading many of the older things that look like candidates for major-hood. [[User:Dakdo|Dakdo]] 00:51, 14 June 2013 (CEST) | The given criteria so far seem to be "completed series quest that someone cared enough to add". There are probably more that could be added (which is why I added the completion dates in comments. Will make inserting new entries easier for whoever does it). Some discussion with Brom after Oren finished prompted the addition of Shoujin and Knight Blades (so Larro's got something in at least. The Game, Sevi, and My Life are his other completed quests- not sure if they count as major or not). I also feel like some of Shot's completed text quests might deserve to be in here. ...main thing holding me back is I haven't gotten around to reading many of the older things that look like candidates for major-hood. [[User:Dakdo|Dakdo]] 00:51, 14 June 2013 (CEST) | ||
The spiel I put in the comment is: | |||
:That means they need to be Series Quests that hit a proper ending. | |||
:There just needs to be a short blurb here since documenting the quest in full is its article's job. If there aren't people around liking the quest enough to provide such, it doesn't belong here! | |||
And from [http://tgchan.org/kusaba/meep/res/364.html#13166 the wiki thread]: | |||
:...the list of nontrivial completed quests: Journey, Bite, Last Flight, that kind of thing. Not all the random one-shots (good as some of them may be) and rocks-falls of Category:Completed_Quests. | |||
It's fuzzy, but it should be the kind of quest most people on the site know roughly about (e.g. could identify unlabeled fanart of it by the characters), generated runs of fanart, that kind of deal. Kind of a showcase of Big Quests TGChan Made, and/or a place to look if you want to sink your teeth into a substantial quest to read that won't leave you hanging with an unfinished ending. | |||
I guess in ''theory'' text quests could fit the bill. :/ --[[User:LionsPhil|LionsPhil]] 13:09, 31 August 2013 (CEST) | |||
Latest revision as of 06:09, 31 August 2013
So hey what are actually the criteria for getting your quest on this page? It seems to be "ran for three or more threads, had images, and reached an end point," but I think we're missing stuff if that's the case (in particular it feels like something by Larro ought to be on here). Typo 00:06, 14 June 2013 (CEST)
The given criteria so far seem to be "completed series quest that someone cared enough to add". There are probably more that could be added (which is why I added the completion dates in comments. Will make inserting new entries easier for whoever does it). Some discussion with Brom after Oren finished prompted the addition of Shoujin and Knight Blades (so Larro's got something in at least. The Game, Sevi, and My Life are his other completed quests- not sure if they count as major or not). I also feel like some of Shot's completed text quests might deserve to be in here. ...main thing holding me back is I haven't gotten around to reading many of the older things that look like candidates for major-hood. Dakdo 00:51, 14 June 2013 (CEST)
The spiel I put in the comment is:
- That means they need to be Series Quests that hit a proper ending.
- There just needs to be a short blurb here since documenting the quest in full is its article's job. If there aren't people around liking the quest enough to provide such, it doesn't belong here!
And from the wiki thread:
- ...the list of nontrivial completed quests: Journey, Bite, Last Flight, that kind of thing. Not all the random one-shots (good as some of them may be) and rocks-falls of Category:Completed_Quests.
It's fuzzy, but it should be the kind of quest most people on the site know roughly about (e.g. could identify unlabeled fanart of it by the characters), generated runs of fanart, that kind of deal. Kind of a showcase of Big Quests TGChan Made, and/or a place to look if you want to sink your teeth into a substantial quest to read that won't leave you hanging with an unfinished ending.
I guess in theory text quests could fit the bill. :/ --LionsPhil 13:09, 31 August 2013 (CEST)
