User:LionsPhil/SemiAutoCatThoughts: Difference between revisions
From questden
Jump to navigationJump to search
(Derpan thoughts about categories given recent Dead Quests confusion) |
m (Variation) |
||
| (6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
All of these states are intended to be mutually exclusive. Recycles board moderator decisions where possible. Exceptional cases are a given. | All of these states are intended to be mutually exclusive (but that doesn't hold rigorously). Recycles board moderator decisions where possible. Exceptional cases are a given. | ||
'''''NB:''' This is just me thinking aloud about what perhaps could be done. It is ''not'' how the current categories work.'' | '''''NB:''' This is just me thinking aloud about what perhaps could be done. It is ''not'' documentation on how the current categories work.'' | ||
Plan B: Merge "Paused" and "Abandoned" into "Stopped". | |||
__NOTOC__ | |||
= Running = | = Running = | ||
;Intent:Quests which are actively updating. | ;Intent:Quests which are actively updating. | ||
| Line 11: | Line 13: | ||
;Intent:Quests which cannot be said to be running right now, but which the author intends to continue. | ;Intent:Quests which cannot be said to be running right now, but which the author intends to continue. | ||
;Purpose:Distinct from Running or Abandoned; a limbo state which doesn't assert either. | ;Purpose:Distinct from Running or Abandoned; a limbo state which doesn't assert either. | ||
;Heuristic:Has no threads on /quest/, has at least one thread in /questarch/. | ;Heuristic:Has no threads on /quest/, has at least one thread in /questarch/. | ||
The most recent thread may have been archived and a new one has not yet started, or it may have been paused so long that it got graveyarded. This would end up catching quests while they are between threads, but that is perhaps correct. People don't tend to be obsessive enough to track this so it basically depends on automated tooling. | |||
= Abandoned = | = Abandoned = | ||
| Line 19: | Line 23: | ||
= Stillborn = | = Stillborn = | ||
;Intent:Quests someone started on a | ;Intent:Quests someone started on a rainy afternoon and got quickly bored of. | ||
;Purpose:Keep all the "chaff" out of the way of quests people might actually care about, so that the latter may be found. | ;Purpose:Keep all the "chaff" out of the way of quests people might actually care about, so that the latter may be found. | ||
;Heuristic:All threads are in /graveyard/. | ;Heuristic:All threads are in /graveyard/. | ||
Intended to be omitted from [[:Category:Quests]] so they don't dilute the list into uselessness. If a stillborn quest had notable impact (e.g. [[DMC Quest]]), probably call it "abandoned" instead. A wrinkle for automated tools. | |||
= Completed = | = Completed = | ||
Latest revision as of 02:47, 5 December 2011
All of these states are intended to be mutually exclusive (but that doesn't hold rigorously). Recycles board moderator decisions where possible. Exceptional cases are a given.
NB: This is just me thinking aloud about what perhaps could be done. It is not documentation on how the current categories work.
Plan B: Merge "Paused" and "Abandoned" into "Stopped".
Running
- Intent
- Quests which are actively updating.
- Purpose
- If you want to get in on a quest and suggest, pick something from this category.
- Heuristic
- Has at least one thread on the /quest/ board.
Paused
- Intent
- Quests which cannot be said to be running right now, but which the author intends to continue.
- Purpose
- Distinct from Running or Abandoned; a limbo state which doesn't assert either.
- Heuristic
- Has no threads on /quest/, has at least one thread in /questarch/.
The most recent thread may have been archived and a new one has not yet started, or it may have been paused so long that it got graveyarded. This would end up catching quests while they are between threads, but that is perhaps correct. People don't tend to be obsessive enough to track this so it basically depends on automated tooling.
Abandoned
- Intent
- Quests which got somewhere but are not expected to ever pick up again and be finished.
- Purpose
- May still be of interest to read what exists of them, especially as characters may have appeared in fanart/ITQ.
- Heuristic
- As for Paused, with manual intervention (e.g. the author has either explicitly said the quest is abandoned, or has left the site).
Stillborn
- Intent
- Quests someone started on a rainy afternoon and got quickly bored of.
- Purpose
- Keep all the "chaff" out of the way of quests people might actually care about, so that the latter may be found.
- Heuristic
- All threads are in /graveyard/.
Intended to be omitted from Category:Quests so they don't dilute the list into uselessness. If a stillborn quest had notable impact (e.g. DMC Quest), probably call it "abandoned" instead. A wrinkle for automated tools.
Completed
- Intent
- Quests that followed through to a narrative ending.
- Purpose
- Complete stories to read.
- Heuristic
- All threads are in /questarch/ (arguably if it has any in /graveyard/ they should probably be moved), author has said it's finished (e.g. by posting a "The End" update).
